Syracuse, N.Y. — The puzzles posed by a strange upcoming high school wrestling season are capsulized underneath the roof of the Ciciarelli home in Liverpool.
Mike, the dad, is an assistant coach for the sport at Cicero-North Syracuse. He’s getting ready for the start of practices, which can begin Monday. As far as what the actual schedule and scope of competition looks like, well those are sort of moving parts right now.
One of Mike’s sons, Anthony, is an eighth-grader. He normally wrestles in the winter and plays baseball in the spring. But he was forced into a tough choice this spring because those two conflict. He’s going to stick with wrestling because he’ll be on the varsity in that sport.
Another son, Vinny, is a sophomore. His typical schedule has him wrestling in the winter and playing lacrosse in the spring. That’s not possible now. So he’s taking time away from the mat to go with lacrosse.
The good sign for all athletes battered by waves of coronavirus bad news is that they now have sports options. The challenge, however, is that some of those choices will be tough ones to make.
“I love lacrosse. I love wrestling. And I didn’t want to pick. But I had to,” Vinny said. “Our whole family is a family of wrestlers. It’s hard.”
Wrestling is normally a winter sport, and a handful of Section III schools opted for limited competition during that window. But most nudged the schedule to the spring, when hopefully the virus has calmed down a bit.
While that makes sense from a precaution standpoint, it forces some wrestlers to choose between sports. The spring is loaded with activities that wrestlers might normally participate in, such as baseball, lacrosse and track and field.
For some, the choice was relatively simple. Vinny Ciciarelli is coming off a knee injury and while he could have wrestled this spring he figured it was a smarter choice to take time off and stick to lacrosse.
For others, it’s a lot tougher. Jackson Taetsch is a senior at West Genesee who normally moves seamlessly from wrestling to lacrosse. Faced with the choice of which to close out his high school career with this spring, he picked lacrosse because he said he’s always liked it a little more.
“It puts kids in a tough situation, even if you felt the same way about both sports,” he said. “My whole life I’ve been able to play both of them. I’ve never had to choose.”
Taetsch’s fellow Wildcat, senior Scott Fura, is taking a different route. Instead of going out for baseball this season, he’s going to try to squeeze out a few more wrestling matches.
“Wrestling is an individuality sport,” Fura said. “It makes me challenge myself. Even though it was a tough choice, I feel like I made the right one.”
Fulton senior wrestler Sam May is turning his back on a chance at history by going with baseball instead this spring. May has 90 career wins, 10 shy needed for a spot on his school’s wall of honor. But May is going to wrestle at The Citadel and has opted for the fun of taking his place at third base for Fulton.
“It was a pretty difficult decision. I might still regret it after awhile,” May said. “As of right now, I still think playing baseball one last time is what I should do.”
There is not a lot of clarity behind the wrestling door this spring. Coaches are trying to figure out how to approach the season as their roster sizes dwindle because some wrestlers are doing other sports.
There will be no sectionals or states. Dual matches are likely out in favor of tri-meets and invitationals, in order to make sure that all wrestlers will have competition.
Fulton coach Jeff Waldron recently said he’s had about 20 wrestlers sign up for the sport, about one-third his normal preseason total. He said because of distanced learning, he’s had far less interaction with students and, therefore, fewer chances to recruit them to the sport.
“My contact with the students is about one-quarter of what it would normally be, maybe less,” Waldron said.
Liverpool coach Steve Lofaso said he normally has a roster of about 60 wrestlers, but is looking at maybe 30-40 now.
“Everybody’s in the same boat,” Lofaso said of his fellow coaches. “Every kid (on the team) will get a ton of wrestling time. Any mat time is a victory for us.”
Besides the conflict of sports, coaches said many parents don’t want their children going out for wrestling because of the virus threat.
“I’m losing some to parents being overly cautious, and rightfully so,” said Cicero-North Syracuse head coach Dave Wise. “I’m trying to tell parents it is safe. But it’s going to be up to the parents in the end whether they want their kids to try it.”
Conflicted athletes are turning to coaches as their sounding board for what choices to make. In general, the advice is to pick whichever sport they most enjoy. That’s especially true for athletes who lost their entire seasons to the coronavirus last spring. And athletes who see wrestling as their primary sport can still pick it back up in the summer.
“I’m telling my kids if you want to play baseball, play baseball. If you want to play lacrosse, play lacrosse. It’s not their fault wrestling landed on top of (the spring season),” Waldron said.
“As long as the kids are competing, what more can we ask for?” said West Genesee wrestling coach Brian McAvan. “How can you hold it (skipping wrestling) against a kid? You can’t. I’m not disappointed. I’m just super-happy that we’re allowed to wrestle.”
Mike Ciciarelli, too, focuses on the positives, especially from the perspective of a parent.
“It’s weird. I’m still going to coach whether they are wrestling or not,” he said. “As a parent, it’s kind of fun to watch them play baseball or lacrosse. So it’s kind of fun to be a dad.”
The payoff isn’t nearly as clear cut for Vinny Ciciarelli. He’ll happily head off to lacrosse practices this spring but will also know that just a short walk away somewhere else in the school’s complex his brother and other friends are going at it on the mat.
“I’m always thinking about getting back in the wrestling room,” Vinny said. “I still say I’m on the team even though I’m not actually wrestling.”
Contact Lindsay Kramer anytime: Email | Twitter
MORE HIGH SCHOOL SPORTS COVERAGE
How a Homer wrestler won 2 ‘state’ titles in one year (8 questions)
HS girls swimming roundup: Records shattered in undefeated Mexico’s dramatic win over Skaneateles
HS football roundup: Homer rolls past Cortland, stays unbeaten
Girls swimming and diving leaders for Section III and the state through April 13
Section III high school sports schedule, scoreboard and live stream info for April 14